How do you know a hunter or gatherer when you see one?

Hunting & Gathering

The reading was Ingold on “Hunting and gathering as ways of perceiving the environment” (40-60) in The Perception of the Environment: Essays on Livelihood, Dwelling and Skill and Brody’s Maps and Dreams: Indians and the British Columbia Frontier (103-135) as part of the Cultural Ecology 2017 course.

The central question: “How do you know a hunter or gatherer when you see one?”

Hunting and Wage Earning

As Brody makes clear–and to a degree this emerges for Ingold as well–in today’s world hunting and gathering is often carried out by people who are involved in the wage economy. It is a contemporary paradox that various forms of “subsistence” production become valued and markers of elite status, as Rudi Colloredo-Mansfeld and I explore in our book Fast, Easy, and In Cash: Artisan Hardship and Hope in the Global Economy, and as Anna Tsing explores in the latter part of this course.

An interesting 2018 research article on these matters is Why Wage Earners Hunt: Food Sharing, Social Structure, and Influence in an Arctic Mixed Economy.

Food sharing in Kangiqsujuaq emerges as a complex social, political, and economic phenomenon that accomplishes different objectives for actors based on their social position. The network approach adopted in this research highlights the conjugate role of individual decisions and structural constraints in broader processes of social and cultural change. In the mixed economy of Kangiqsujuaq, food sharing, social structure, and political influence are intimately connected. The results suggest that economic and political inequality in the settlement are reinforced by the social structures produced through sharing.

While I am not surprised by the fact that traditional food sharing occurs at the top of the internal hierarchy, I would take issue with the idea that economic and political inequality is “reinforced” by such sharing. “Reinforced” can have a range of meanings, and I would doubt that food sharing would have a strong causal effect for inequality, as has been posited in the title of a press release For Inuit, sharing traditional foods only increases social inequality.

Or, more strongly put:

And in the analysis of anthropologist Helga Vierich:

To cite: Antrosio, Jason. 2017. “How do you know a hunter or gatherer when you see one?” Living Anthropologically website, First posted 15 February 2017. Revised 13 March 2018.

Living Anthropologically brings anthropology to life & public debates. Anthropology documents possibility & creativity to effect change. For updates, follow on Twitter or subscribe.

Please consider contributing to Living Anthropologically. Contributions help bring anthropology to public debates. Not tax-deductible. For more, see Support Living Anthropologically.