Is Evolution a Myth?!

Course: Intro-to-Anthro 2021 | Book: Anthropology: What Does it Mean to Be Human?

Both the Desana creation story and evolutionary theory are myths in the anthropological sense — “stories that recount how various aspects of the world came to be the way they are” (Lavenda and Schultz 24). The anthropological definition of myth makes no claim about truth value; it identifies the story type. What separates a scientific story from a mythic story is fit with evidence and the discipline of falsifiability.

This page is the canonical treatment on the site for the scientific-method angle of evolutionary theory: the anthropological definition of myth, falsifiability and the aliens hypothesis, the critique of intelligent design, safely non-falsifiable hypotheses, the difference between scientific and popular uses of “theory,” and Bruno Latour’s laboratory ethnography. For the live-curriculum treatment of evolutionary theory broadly — Darwin’s “descent with modification” and Herbert Spencer’s borrowed “survival of the fittest” — see Evolutionary Theory: Goodbye to Survival of the Fittest. For the L&S companion treatment of evolutionary theory and diversity, see Evolution and Diversity.

Is Evolution a Myth? Anthropology, Falsifiability, and Scientific Theory

Key Concepts

  • Myth (anthropological definition) — Lavenda and Schultz define myths as “stories that recount how various aspects of the world came to be the way they are” (24). The Desana creation story and the physics story of the universe’s origins are both myths in this sense. The anthropological use of “myth” does not mean “false story.”
  • What makes a story scientific — A scientific story has to match observations and evidence. If ideas don’t fit observations, scientists must reject them “regardless of the consequences” and “invent better ones” (24). Those consequences can be professional, financial, or social — and people often resist rejecting ideas they are invested in.
  • Falsifiability — Science does not “prove” hypotheses. It tries to falsify them. If a hypothesis withstands sustained attempts to disprove it, it remains a good candidate. Most major scientific publications are disproving earlier ideas — that is how science self-corrects.
  • The aliens hypothesis — Saying “aliens planted these fossils” is initially testable. But responding “the aliens were too clever to leave evidence” creates a non-falsifiable claim. Lavenda and Schultz: such a statement “holds no scientific interest” (28).
  • Intelligent design — Lavenda and Schultz frame intelligent design as the same problem dressed up. “The world is complex, there must be a designer” cannot be tested or falsified. It carries the rhetorical flair of science without the falsifiability that makes a hypothesis scientific.
  • Safely non-falsifiable hypotheses — Some hypotheses may be true even though evidence has been destroyed. The Coastal Migration Route into the Americas — people moving down the Pacific coast 15,000 years ago — is a plausible explanation for early artifact assemblages, but rising sea levels have obliterated most archaeological sites.
  • Theory in science vs. theory in popular use — In popular use, “theory” means a wild guess. In science, “theory” means an idea supported by multiple testable hypotheses and a body of evidence (Lavenda and Schultz 28). The theory of gravity. Atomic theory. Evolutionary theory. The everyday and scientific meanings are nearly opposite.
  • The “evolution is a theory” sticker — Some states required textbook stickers reading “evolution is a theory” — trading on the popular sense to undermine the scientific sense. Yes, evolution is a theory. In the scientific sense, that is a strong claim, not a weak one.
  • Science studies — Lavenda and Schultz close the chapter with science studies (30): anthropological and other research on how science actually works in practice. Science is not insulated from society; it responds to financial incentives, politics, and economics.
  • Bruno Latour and laboratory ethnography — Latour’s “laboratory ethnography” (30) studies scientists using the same methods anthropologists use to study other societies. The result is “a more accurate, if less exalted view” (30) of how science makes sense of the world.

This page reflects the lecture from Intro to Anthropology 2021, following What Is Anthropology?, reading module 2, “Anthropology, Science, and Storytelling” in Lavenda and Schultz’s Anthropology: What Does It Mean to Be Human? (Commissions earned). The course no longer uses Lavenda and Schultz, but this page remains the canonical treatment on the site for the scientific-method angle.

Comparing Desana Creation and Physics

Lavenda and Schultz begin with a comparison of the Desana creation story from the Amazon and the scientific explanation from physics (23-24). Both are myths in the anthropological sense. The Desana story is more fun to read — there is the sun, the sun does stuff, it is cool. The physics story tries to bore us in a textbook. But both are stories about how the world came to be.

In the anthropological use of myth, we are not deciding which is ultimately true or false. We record that they are stories making the universe make sense to us. Myths are not equivalent to falsehoods; they are a story type. The Desana creation story is a meaningful, valuable myth. The physics story of the universe’s origins is also a myth in this anthropological sense — and also a scientific story, because it is grounded in observations and evidence.

What Makes a Story Scientific

To be a scientific story, the narrative must match observations and evidence. As Lavenda and Schultz put it, if ideas about how the world works can be shown not to fit observations, scientists must reject those ideas, “regardless of the consequences,” and “invent better ones” (24).

What are those consequences? People get attached to their ideas. There can be professional consequences — fame, publications, status. There can be financial consequences — funding pulled if your hypothesis about a disease-curing ingredient falls apart. There can be social consequences — beliefs you have to give up that you and your community held. The discipline of science is being willing to reject ideas even when the consequences are costly. The frequent failure of scientists to do this is part of what science studies investigates.

Don’t take “we reject ideas that don’t fit” as cause for despair about scientific knowledge. We may not have conclusive proof of anything, and we cannot take a time machine to the age of the dinosaurs. But we have evidence, and we have scientific debate, and we can say a lot about what happened in the past. A lot of evidence is missing — most creatures actively avoid becoming fossils. But what is missing is not nothing. The point of science is to keep making ideas better fit the evidence we do have.

The Creationism/Evolution “Controversy”

Lavenda and Schultz subtly introduce what some have called the “creation/evolution controversy.” In actuality there is no scientific controversy. One story fits the evidence; the other does not. This is not a case where reasonable scientific debate continues — it is one of the things that, within science, is basically settled.

That does not mean creation stories are unimportant. They are meaningful, distinctive, anthropologically important. They tell us about the meaning of life and how communities make sense of existence. The Desana creation story is great. Other creation stories are great. They are simply not scientific stories.

A note for context: I grew up in a creationist environment. I am not interested in upsetting anyone’s beliefs or telling anyone that their myths are terrible. These stories are still interesting and important. The goal is for students to be able to understand why science has come to certain conclusions, what is actually up for debate within science, and what is basically settled.

One caricature of evolution that gets thrown around: “I saw monkeys in South America. If evolution is true, why aren’t those monkeys turning into people?” That was a powerful argument when I was a kid. It is also a caricature — that is not what evolution actually asserts. Looking at what evolution actually claims matters more than knocking down weird misrepresentations of it.

The Aliens Hypothesis and Falsifiability

The “aliens hypothesis” proposes that artifacts, fossils, pyramids, or other puzzling objects were placed by extraterrestrial beings (Lavenda and Schultz 28). At first this is testable: search for evidence of alien intervention. None has turned up. The hypothesis is falsified.

Science often works through this kind of attempted falsification rather than through proof. You come up with a hypothesis. You try to disprove it. If you cannot, it stays in play. Most major scientific publications are disproving ideas we previously held — which can be frustrating (“they can’t prove anything!”) but is exactly how self-correcting knowledge works.

The aliens hypothesis becomes non-falsifiable when proponents respond to the lack of evidence with “the aliens were too clever to leave any.” If you cannot find evidence because, by design, no evidence could ever appear, your hypothesis has stepped outside science. Lavenda and Schultz: such a statement “holds no scientific interest” (28). It can still hold other kinds of interest — clickbait interest, entertainment interest, book-selling interest. Just not scientific interest.

Intelligent Design as Non-Falsifiable

Lavenda and Schultz’ treatment of the aliens hypothesis is, in part, a subtle response to intelligent design — a framework that became popular as a more scientific-sounding rebranding of creationism. The pitch: the world is complex, many things are difficult to explain, everything seems to fit together — so there must be a designer.

This carries the rhetorical flair of science. Attaching the word “intelligent” to the framework makes it sound smart in a way that “creationism” no longer does for many audiences. But intelligent design has the same logical structure as the post-hoc aliens defense: you look at the world, identify things that are hard to explain, and conclude that an unobservable designer must be behind them. There is no way to test or falsify the claim. Whoever designed humans to walk upright — which causes back pain, knee problems, and lifelong wear on hips and feet — we should get them on the phone and have them rethink the human design.

Hypotheses with Limited Evidence: The Coastal Migration Route

Not every hypothesis that lacks evidence is unscientific. Some hypotheses may be true but cannot be easily tested because the relevant evidence has been destroyed or is otherwise inaccessible.

The Coastal Migration Route into the Americas is a good example. It proposes that people from Asia entered the Americas by traveling down the Pacific coast, perhaps as early as 15,000 years ago. The problem is that sea levels have risen since the end of the last ice age, obliterating most of the archaeological sites where coastal migrants would have lived. Some researchers call this a “safely non-falsifiable hypothesis” — it seems to fit the patterns we see (early artifact assemblages spread widely across the Americas), but direct evidence is hard to produce.

So there are two different kinds of hypotheses that lack evidence. One: hypotheses that probably hold true but whose direct evidence has been destroyed (Coastal Migration Route). Two: hypotheses designed to be impossible to falsify so they can sell books or generate clicks (the post-hoc aliens defense). Scientists have to distinguish between these.

Theory in Science vs. Theory in Popular Use

In everyday language, “theory” implies uncertainty. The friend who comes into your room at 2 a.m. saying “I have a theory” gets met with a polite “go to bed.” We hear about “conspiracy theorists” spouting obviously wrong ideas. The word “theory” in popular use has come to mean almost the opposite of what scientists mean by it.

Lavenda and Schultz on scientific theory: “scientists speak of a scientific theory only when they are able to link up a series of testable hypotheses in a coherent manner to explain a body of material evidence” (28). When scientists use the word “theory,” it is a big jump — above the level of hypotheses. It links together many tested hypotheses with a large amount of evidence to explain something substantial about how the world works. Theory of gravity. Atomic theory. Evolutionary theory.

For a stretch some states required textbook stickers reading “evolution is just a theory,” banking on the popular sense to undermine the scientific sense. The strategy turns the linguistic ambiguity into a wedge. Yes, evolution is a theory — meaning, in scientific terms, that it has the highest support a scientific claim can have, not that it is a wild guess.

For the broader treatment of evolutionary theory in anthropology — how Darwin and Spencer fit together, why “descent with modification” is more accurate than “survival of the fittest,” and the modern evolutionary synthesis — see Evolutionary Theory: Goodbye to Survival of the Fittest.

Bruno Latour, Laboratory Ethnography, and Science Studies

The scientific method matters. The discipline of falsifying ideas that do not fit the evidence matters. But science is not insulated from society. Scientists respond to financial incentives, political pressures, social context, professional reputation. Science studies — the anthropological and historical research on how science is actually done — examines these realities.

The French sociologist and anthropologist Bruno Latour made laboratory ethnography famous (Lavenda and Schultz 30). Ethnography is traditionally what anthropologists do when they live with and study other societies and write about what they find. Latour and his collaborators did the same thing in scientific laboratories, observing how scientists actually do their work. What scientific method gets used in practice? When are hypotheses really rejected? What happens to data that does not fit? How are findings written up, published, and turned into accepted knowledge?

Lavenda and Schultz quote the science-studies tradition as providing “a more accurate, if less exalted view” (30) of how science works. The view is less exalted because the pure-method picture (scientists going into the lab with nothing but the scientific method, generating ever-better cures) does not match what happens. Antibiotics were wonderful — and immediately put us into an evolutionary race with bacteria evolving to evade treatment. Every advance comes with trade-offs. Understanding the biases, pressures, and institutional dynamics that affect science is what makes science improvable.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the anthropological definition of myth? Anthropologists use “myth” technically to refer to “stories that recount how various aspects of the world came to be the way they are” (Lavenda and Schultz 24). This definition makes no claim about truth value. A myth in this sense can be a creation story from an Indigenous community, a religious account of origins, or a physics textbook’s account of the universe’s beginning. All three are stories explaining how the world came to be. The anthropological use of “myth” is different from the popular use, where “myth” usually means “false story.”

What makes a story scientific rather than mythic? A scientific story is grounded in observations and evidence. When ideas do not fit observations, scientists must reject those ideas — “regardless of the consequences” — and develop better ones (Lavenda and Schultz 24). The discipline of falsifiability separates scientific stories from other meaningful stories about how the world came to be. The Desana creation story and the physics story of the universe’s origins are both myths in the anthropological sense; only one is grounded in falsifiable hypotheses tested against evidence.

Why is intelligent design not a scientific hypothesis? Intelligent design argues that the complexity of the world implies a designer. This claim is non-falsifiable — there is no observation that could be made which would disprove the existence of an unobservable designer. Lavenda and Schultz argue that non-falsifiable claims “hold no scientific interest” (28). Intelligent design carries the rhetorical flair of science (the word “intelligent” attached to it; references to complexity and design) without the falsifiability that distinguishes scientific hypotheses from other kinds of claims. The same logical structure underlies the post-hoc defense of the aliens hypothesis (“the aliens were too clever to leave evidence”).

What is the difference between scientific theory and everyday “theory”? In everyday usage, “theory” implies uncertainty or speculation — “I have a theory” often means “I have a guess.” In science, “theory” denotes an idea supported by multiple testable hypotheses and a substantial body of evidence (Lavenda and Schultz 28). Theory of gravity, atomic theory, and evolutionary theory are theories in the scientific sense — strongly supported frameworks explaining significant phenomena. The two meanings are nearly opposite, and the slippage between them has been used (with the “evolution is just a theory” stickers, for instance) to suggest that scientific evolution is weakly supported when the opposite is true.

What is laboratory ethnography? Laboratory ethnography is the application of anthropological fieldwork methods to scientific laboratories. Rather than studying scientists’ methods from a distance, laboratory ethnographers live with and observe scientists at work, documenting how science is actually practiced — what hypotheses get tested, how data are managed, how findings are written up and circulated, what social and institutional dynamics shape research. Bruno Latour is the best-known practitioner. Lavenda and Schultz cite laboratory ethnography (30) as part of science studies, which aims to give “a more accurate, if less exalted view” (30) of scientific practice.

Course Navigation

← Previous: What Is Anthropology?
→ Next: Evolution and Diversity
🎓 Course home: Intro to Anthropology 2021 (Lavenda and Schultz)
🌍 Hub: Human Origins
📚 Live-curriculum theory canonical: Evolutionary Theory: Goodbye to Survival of the Fittest