Beyond the Gender Binary

What lies beyond the male/female binary—and could we imagine alternatives not just to the binary but to gender itself? This lecture, from Cultural Anthropology, moves through two-spirit roles, hijra and sadhin, the intersex prevalence debate, transgender identity and sport, and ends with Tom Boellstorff’s proposal to drop “he” and “she” from English. It follows the first part of the gender chapter; for the foundational sex/gender treatment, see Sex and Gender Anthropology.

📖 Introducing Anthropology (Pountney & Marić): available here (Commissions earned). We also read anthropologist Tom Boellstorff’s essay “Why English Might Let Go of ‘He’ and ‘She’.”

Key Concepts

  • Beyond the binary—and beyond gender. Most of life is spent inside a gender binary reinforced from birth (a gender reveal party never “fires the intersex cannon”). This lecture asks about alternatives to the binary, and finally about alternatives to gender itself.
  • Two-Spirit. Many Indigenous American societies recognized third and fourth gender roles (documented by Will Roscoe); colonizers persecuted them—sometimes fatally, with church sanction—and the old anthropological term “berdache” (a French slur) is no longer used. Some communities reclaim these roles today.
  • The “queerest continent.” The Americas held gender diversity far more radical than anything recent, long before Europeans arrived—much of it destroyed by colonialism, some of it now being recovered.
  • Hijra and sadhin. Serena Nanda’s Neither Man Nor Woman: The Hijras of India documents the hijra (who can draw on Hindu sexually ambivalent figures yet remain persecuted); the sadhin are a less visible, more persecuted category. Third and fourth genders appear on every continent and in every era.
  • Intersex, not “intersexuality.” A terminology point that matters—sex is not sexuality. Intersex people are born with, or develop, sex characteristics that are ambiguous or combined, some not visible at birth.
  • The prevalence debate. Estimates run from 1.7% (Intersex Human Rights Australia, about as common as red hair) down to 0.018% (~1 in 10,000), depending on what counts; the lecturer lands near 1 in 1,000. The intersex community argues against rushing infant “corrective” surgery.
  • Fausto-Sterling’s “Five Sexes.” Anne Fausto-Sterling argued that our gender binary makes us force biological sex into a binary. Sex is often binary—but our insistence makes it more rigidly so than the biology (XXY, X0, and more) warrants.
  • Transgender and language. “Transgenderism” is a non-word (there’s no such ideology); sport and testosterone testing show the trouble with hard categories; and Tom Boellstorff proposes retiring “he” and “she” for a universal “they”—English already has gender-neutral “I,” “we,” and “you.”

Beyond the Gender Binary

Most societies operate within a gender binary reinforced from birth—as the lecture puts it, a gender reveal party fires a pink or blue cannon, never an “intersex cannon.” We can talk about inequalities within the binary, about people crossing between its categories, and about people who don’t feel at home in it, but the conversation almost always stays inside two boxes. This lecture takes two further steps: first to alternatives to the binary (other societies’ third and fourth genders), and then to the more radical question of an alternative to gender itself.

Two-Spirit People

Many Native American and Indigenous communities across the Americas recognized people who took on the roles of another gender or occupied a distinct social role of their own. European colonizers, especially the French, applied the derogatory term “berdache” (originally meaning a male prostitute), and missionaries and colonizers persecuted these individuals, sometimes putting them to death with church sanction. Anthropologist Will Roscoe documented these as third genders (males performing female tasks or holding special roles) and fourth genders (females performing male tasks or holding special roles). The gender diversity of the pre-contact Americas was, in a phrase sometimes attributed to Roscoe, that of “the queerest continent”—a modern label projected backward, but pointing at something real. Much was eliminated by colonialism; some communities are reclaiming these identities today, often preferring terms from their own languages over the pan-Indigenous “two-spirit.”

The Mojave Male Gender Variant

Among the Mojave, a boy who began acting differently before the puberty ceremony might take on a male gender variant role. Parents did not necessarily celebrate it, and acceptance varied—some groups treated it as a special role, others tolerated it as less than ideal—but it was recognized as a place in the gender system rather than an aberration, one more alternative to a strict binary.

Hijra and Sadhin

Serena Nanda‘s Neither Man Nor Woman: The Hijras of India documents this well-known third-gender community. What struck the class was the religious dimension: Hinduism offers sexually ambivalent figures the hijra can draw upon (the lecturer notes Christianity offers no obvious equivalent). Even so, the hijra remain a persecuted identity, respected in certain ritual contexts but marginalized overall. The sadhin—the subject of Nanda’s earlier article “The Hijras and the Sadhins of India”—are less visible and more persecuted, lacking the community structure the hijra have built. The lesson: alternative gender categories are real and widespread (hundreds of examples, on every continent and in every era), but they are not equally recognized or protected.

Thai and Philippine Gender Diversity

Another of Nanda’s studies takes up the transvestite beauty contests and gender identities that have developed in Thailand and the Philippines. These are hybrid formations—drawing on local traditional identities while also absorbing globalized ideas of beauty and glamour from the “global north” and the United States.

Intersex, Not “Intersexuality”

The textbook slips here, writing “intersexuality” where it means intersex—a real distinction, since the course insists on separating sex, gender, and sexuality. Intersex describes people born with, or who develop, sex characteristics that are ambiguous, combined, or otherwise atypical; some are not visible at birth. The prevalence estimates range widely: Intersex Human Rights Australia puts it at 1.7% of the population (about as common as red hair), while stricter definitions yield 0.018% (closer to 1 in 10,000). The gap depends on what counts—many chromosomal or genetic conditions (XXY, X0) never manifest phenotypically and may go unnoticed for a lifetime. Weighing this, the lecturer estimates somewhere near 1 in 1,000. Historically, infants born with ambiguous genitalia were “fixed” by quick surgical decision; the intersex community now argues for waiting rather than rushing to operate.

Anne Fausto-Sterling: The Binary That Makes the Binary

Anne Fausto-Sterling‘s article “The Five Sexes: Why Male and Female Are Not Enough” pushed the argument that our gender binary shapes how we see biological sex. The lecturer’s own settled view: sex is often binary, but our training to see gender as binary makes us insist that sex be more rigidly binary than the biology supports—we are eager to “fix” people onto one side or the other when the underlying reality is messier. Understanding this, the lecture suggests, belongs in sex education—where it currently isn’t.

Transgender, Not “Transgenderism”

Another textbook slip: “transgenderism” names no actual ideology; the word is simply transgender, for people transitioning or identifying differently than assigned at birth. Sport is the hard case, where the desire for clean categories runs into biology: naturally occurring testosterone varies widely among both women and men, and whether it confers an athletic advantage depends on the event. These questions will keep being worked out—but the anthropological point stands that human societies have always done gender in many ways, and much of the present discomfort comes from a society’s insistence on the binary.

Queer Identity and Festivals

European queer festivals function as spaces of identity formation—places to experiment, find others, and build community. The lecture notes a nice detail: even veganism can become part of festival identity, adopted for the gathering rather than practiced in ordinary life. The deeper point connects to sexuality across cultures: acts we might classify as homosexual or queer have always existed, but an identity requires visibility, other people, and usually urban concentration—which is exactly what a festival supplies.

Should English Drop “He” and “She”?

The lecture closes with Tom Boellstorff‘s essay proposing to retire “he” and “she” in favor of a universal “they.” Boellstorff is not against stating preferred pronouns—he calls it a good thing—but he argues it doesn’t challenge gender exclusion, and can even reinforce it, and it never solves the problem of what to call people you haven’t met. English, unlike heavily gendered languages such as French or Spanish, is already close to gender-neutral: “I,” “we,” and “you” carry no gender. The final push, he suggests, is simply “they,” which is spreading on its own; he asks English-speaking cisgender allies to give up “she” and “he” in the name of radical gender inclusion. The class discussion surfaces the real complication (also raised in Boellstorff’s essay): would people moving to “they” absorb a category that non-binary people have claimed, and would those who embrace “woman” as a hard-won political category lose ground? The question stays open—something, the lecturer figures, to be worked out over the next few years.

Questions This Lecture Answers

What is Two-Spirit, and why avoid “berdache”? Two-Spirit is an umbrella term for third- and fourth-gender roles recognized across many Indigenous American societies—social roles, not biological categories. “Berdache,” a French slur once standard in the anthropological literature, is avoided today; communities often prefer their own languages’ terms.

How common is intersex? It depends on the definition. A broad count (Intersex Human Rights Australia) reaches 1.7%, about as common as red hair; a strict one is 0.018%, near 1 in 10,000. The lecturer, noting that many conditions don’t manifest at birth, estimates around 1 in 1,000—and stresses the intersex community’s call to slow down infant surgery.

What did Fausto-Sterling argue in “The Five Sexes”? That our binary view of gender pushes us to force biological sex into a binary too. Sex is often binary, but our insistence makes it seem more rigidly so than the biology (with variations like XXY and X0) actually is.

What is Boellstorff’s pronoun proposal? To drop “he” and “she” from English in favor of a universal “they,” building on the gender-neutral “I,” “we,” and “you” English already has—a step toward radical gender inclusion, with open questions about how it interacts with non-binary and feminist claims on identity.

Continue Exploring

Previous: Gender (is gender inequality biology, capitalism, or culture?) — Next: Globalisation

Related: Sex and Gender Anthropology; the anthropology of gender hub.