Is gender inequality biology?

Is gender inequality rooted in biology, in capitalism, or in culture? This 2021 lecture, from Cultural Anthropology, builds on Gayle Rubin’s 1975 “The Traffic in Women,” whose three possible answers each imply a different feminist program. It works through all three—and through Sherry Ortner’s nature/culture argument, Marilyn Strathern’s and African feminists’ critiques, and Andean complementarity. For the foundational sex/gender distinction, see Sex and Gender Anthropology; the next class takes up alternative gender identities.

📖 Introducing Anthropology (Pountney & Marić): available here (Commissions earned)

Key Concepts

  • Rubin’s three answers. Gayle Rubin’s 1975 “The Traffic in Women” opens by asking whether the root of women’s oppression is innate biology, capitalism, or a cultural-historical defeat—because each answer implies a different feminist program (288). It is the discipline’s sharpest “so what does theory have to do with activism?” question.
  • Not biology. Sexual dimorphism between women and men is limited, overlapping, and has decreased over human evolution and as diets and activities equalize (282); in any group some women are stronger and faster than some men.
  • Sex versus gender. Feminism’s key move: sex names biological difference, gender the social roles and expectations attached to it—so the same biology carries wildly different expectations across societies and time.
  • Not simply capitalism. Wage labor and stored wealth do exacerbate gender inequality, but hunter-gatherer societies (the San) show gender asymmetry too, and 1970s anti-capitalist movements were often masculinist—inequality did not fade in actually existing socialism.
  • Ortner’s nature/culture. Sherry Ortner proposed that women are universally associated with nature and men with culture, with culture valued above nature—a productive account of male dominance that turned out not to hold everywhere.
  • Strathern’s critique. Marilyn Strathern, working in Papua New Guinea, argued that the nature/culture divide (and culture’s supposed superiority) is itself a Western imposition, and that persons are not everywhere sorted into fixed male/female types.
  • African feminist critiques. Oyèrónkẹ́ Oyěwùmí (The Invention of Women) argues the very category “women” is a Western construction; Ifi Amadiume (Male Daughters, Female Husbands) shows sex and gender did not coincide in pre-colonial Igbo society.
  • Culture can equalize. Matrilineal societies (the Hopi), near-equal societies (the Vanatinai), and Andean complementarity show cultures distributing power more evenly—though “separate but equal” always deserves skepticism.

Is Gender Inequality Biology, Capitalism, or Culture?

The lecture is organized around three sentences that open Gayle Rubin’s 1975 essay “The Traffic in Women,” written when Rubin was a 26-year-old graduate student. Each sentence names a possible root of women’s oppression, and each implies a very different plan of action—which is exactly why the lecturer calls them a model of the “so what” question, the link between theory and activism. If the root is innate male biology, Rubin notes, “the feminist program would logically require either the extermination of the offending sex, or a eugenics project to modify its character.” If it is capitalism, “sexism would wither away in the advent of a successful socialist revolution.” And if it is a cultural-historical defeat, “it is time for Amazon guerrillas to start training in the Adirondacks.” The rest of the class takes the three in turn.

Is It Biology?

No. As the chapter notes (282), sexual dimorphism between women and men is modest next to many primate species, has grown smaller over human evolution, and shrinks further whenever diets and activities are equalized—in the old pattern boys got the protein and girls the carbohydrates, which itself built different bodies. Across most physical traits the female and male ranges overlap, which “casts doubt over the relevance of sexual dimorphism today.” This is where the feminist distinction between sex (biological difference) and gender (the social roles attached to it) does its work: the same biology comes with different expectations everywhere you look. (The familiar slip, calling a “sex reveal party” a “gender reveal party,” runs the two together—an ultrasound reveals sex, while the gender expectations get loaded on early.)

Is It Capitalism?

Partly, but not at the root. Among horticulturalists and hunter-gatherers, male and female roles often overlap and are interchangeable, and with little way to store wealth, large inequalities are hard to build; introducing wage labor, providers, and bank accounts tends to rev gender inequality up. That cuts against the comfortable belief that our own society is the most liberated—colonialism and capitalism have often produced more inequality than many traditional societies carried. But it cannot be only capitalism: even in a classic hunter-gatherer case like the San (Richard Lee’s study), women supplied most of the calories through gathering while men’s hunting drew the excitement and prestige. And the 1970s anti-capitalist movements were themselves frequently masculinist—feminism emerged in part because the Marxists were so male-oriented—while inequality did not simply fade in actually existing socialism.

Is It Culture? Ortner and Her Critics

That leaves culture, and the chapter revisits Sherry Ortner’s famous formulation: is female to male as nature is to culture? Because of functions like lactation, menstruation, and childbirth, women get associated with the rooted, earthy, natural side of life, while men occupy public, political “culture”—and where culture is valued over nature, male dominance follows. It is a genuinely productive idea, but it frayed on closer inspection.

First, the public/private divide does not map neatly onto gender: in the lecturer’s own Latin American fieldwork, women ran the marketplace (public) while men farmed (the more domestic task). Second, Marilyn Strathern‘s work in Papua New Guinea showed that a sharp nature/culture split, with culture superior, is a Western way of carving up the world, not a universal one. Third, the 1970s feminists making these arguments were largely Western and White, and missed other perspectives: Oyèrónkẹ́ Oyěwùmí‘s The Invention of Women argues that the category “women” is itself a Western construction tied to visual representation, and Ifi Amadiume‘s Male Daughters, Female Husbands: Gender and Sex in an African Society shows that in pre-colonial society sex and gender did not necessarily coincide. Ortner herself later granted that “universal male dominance” was likely overstated. The chapter lands on a careful phrasing: perhaps not universal patriarchy, but a near-universal patriarchal ideology.

Where Culture Equalizes

The reading closes with societies that distribute roles more evenly. Among the Hopi and other matrilineal societies across the Americas and beyond, inheritance, land, and names pass through the female line—which does not make them matriarchies (there are no known mirror-image matriarchies) but can even things out. The Vanatinai reach near gender equality. And in the Andes, Andean complementarity (or parallelism), a pre-Hispanic idea among groups like the Aymara studied by Andrew Canessa, treats women and men as different but genuinely interdependent—you need both to make a whole social person (someone who dies unmarried may be buried with a non-human animal of the opposite sex). The lecturer keeps a healthy skepticism—”separate but equal” usually hides inequality—while allowing that a deep tradition like this may carry it off more honestly than the phrase usually does.

From Gender to Sexuality: Activities Everywhere, Identities Recent

The section ends by turning to sexuality, and by keeping it distinct from gender: gender is about ideas attached to biological difference, sexuality about how people are erotic and reproductive with one another. Across human societies, heterosexual and homosexual acts occur everywhere—but that people carry an identity as “gay” or “straight” is recent, argued by some to emerge only around the 1950s in the United States. A famous example (289): in many Latin American settings a man who has sex with other men is not thereby “homosexual”—the penetrating partner keeps a heterosexual identity, and only the receptive partner is categorized otherwise. This is not a curiosity: public-health work on HIV in Africa initially looked for Western-style gay identities and missed the activity that was actually occurring.

These threads feed queer theory, where the slur “queer” was reclaimed as resistance to imposed norms. Gayle Rubin’s work runs into it, and so do the ideas of Judith Butler, whose Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity argues that gender is something we perform—learned early, rewarded when done “well” and penalized when not, so that it comes to feel natural even though it is developed, changeable, and performed across a life.

Questions This Lecture Answers

Is gender inequality biology, capitalism, or culture? Gayle Rubin framed these as the three options, each implying a different feminist program (288). The lecture’s reading: not biology (sexual dimorphism is limited and shrinking, 282), not simply capitalism (though it exacerbates inequality), but largely cultural and historical—while cautioning that patriarchal ideology is “almost” universal, with the “almost” doing real work.

Does sexual dimorphism prove natural gender roles? No. Male/female differences in size and strength are modest, overlapping, and have decreased over evolution and with more equal diets and activities (282). Real biological differences exist, but they do not determine social roles.

Does Ortner’s “nature is to culture as female is to male” hold everywhere? No. The public/private divide does not track gender consistently, Marilyn Strathern showed the nature/culture split is a Western imposition, and African feminists (Oyěwùmí, Amadiume) showed that even “women” and the sex/gender alignment are not universal. Ortner later called her universal claim overstated.

Are “gay” and “straight” universal identities? No. Same-sex and different-sex acts occur in all societies, but sexual identity is a recent development (some argue 1950s U.S.). In many Latin American contexts identity turns on sexual role rather than partner’s sex (289), with real consequences for public health.

Continue Exploring

Next: Alternative Gender Identities — Two-Spirit, hijra, intersex, and social gender beyond the binary.

Related (each covers a distinct angle): Sex and Gender Anthropology (foundational, with archaeological evidence) · Feminist Anthropology (Leacock, Bourgois, Amadiume, Anzaldúa) · the anthropology of gender hub.