In Cultural Anthropology 2021, we explored Michel-Rolph Trouillot’s critique of globalization narratives. For comprehensive treatment, see What is Globalization in Anthropology? (2024).
This material followed Phases of Globalization and preceded Boundaries.
Trouillot’s Critique: The Silencing of History
“For sushi in Chicago to amaze us, we need to silence the fact that the Franciscans were in Japan as early as the fifteenth century. For Muslim veils in France to seem out of place, we need to forget that Charles Martel stopped Abd-al-Rahman only 300 miles south of Paris two reigns before Charlemagne. To talk of a global culture today as a new phenomenon, we need to forget that Chinese chili paste comes from Mexico, French fries from Peru, and Jamaican Blue Mountain coffee from Yemen.” (Trouillot, 34)
Trouillot argues globalization narratives systematically erase deep historical encounters:
- Battle of Tours (732 AD): Muslim armies reached 300 miles from Paris
- Potatoes from Peru saved Northern Europe, corn transformed Africa within 60 years
- Fur trade wealth amplified potlatch ceremonies
- Horses transformed Native American cultures despite being European imports
The National Interlude (1930s-1970s)
Why does globalization feel new? A nationalist period created artificial separation:
- 1910: US foreign-born population near 15% (peak)
- 1970: Under 5% (lowest ever)
- 2018: 13.7% (still below 1910)
This retreat from global connections makes current interconnection seem unprecedented.
What’s Actually New?
1. Finance Over Production
- “We don’t make steel, we make money” – U.S. Steel
- Enron: From oil to derivatives to collapse
- Gamification of investing through apps
- Cryptocurrency: Value exists only through belief
2. Gadgets Over Infrastructure
Oneonta once had the world’s largest train roundhouse, flights to NYC, and rail connections. Now struggles for bus service. “People will put up with the shittiest conditions if they have Wi-Fi.”
3. Speed Over Depth
Eriksen’s “acceleration” (346): Prioritizing quick communication over quality, shorter paragraphs, instant posts.
4. Multipolar Economics
- China’s GDP approaching US levels
- Rise of Japan, South Korea, India, Brazil
- Belt and Road Initiative: New Silk Road
Post-2020 Shifts
COVID disrupted acceleration culture, prompting re-examination of “slow living.” China’s Belt and Road contrasts with US infrastructure decay. Climate change and racial justice movements suggest emerging global citizenship, though ethno-nationalism persists.
Problematic Terms
- “Creolization”: Sidney Mintz argued this describes specific Caribbean experiences under slavery, not casual cultural mixing
- “Hybridity”: Implies previous purity, ignoring centuries of interconnection
Both terms erase power relations and specific histories of creativity under oppression.
Recap: Trouillot’s Warning
Essential Resources
- 2024: What is Globalization in Anthropology? (canonical treatment)
- How Silver, Sugar, and Slavery Built Global Capitalism
- Three Phases Framework
- Michel-Rolph Trouillot’s Global Transformations